Standfirst: Axel Scheffler, the artist behind The Gruffalo since 1999, says he has contacted a lawyer in Germany and is seriously considering suing AI firms he believes have copied his Gruffalo and his mouse into AI-generated scenes without permission.

Axel Scheffler, the Gruffalo illustrator whose drawings have appeared in children’s books since 1999, has told the BBC he has contacted a lawyer in Germany and is seriously considering legal action against AI companies over what he calls “theft of copyright” of his work.

Scheffler told BBC London he wants AI firms to stop using artists’ work without permission, after someone showed him his characters digitally recreated in locations such as Silicon Valley and Oktoberfest. “It’s clearly my mouse, my Gruffalo, as close as they can do it, but the rest of the image is completely created, it’s a clear theft of copyright,” he said, according to the BBC. He did not name a company his legal team would consider pursuing, the BBC reports, and said he is weighing the case in Germany because he believes the European Union offers a more creator-friendly route.

Why it matters to small business owners

Plenty of small firms now use AI image tools for marketing, social posts or product mock-ups, often without thinking hard about where the training data came from. This case puts a spotlight on exactly that question: if a famous, distinctive character can turn up in AI output without the creator’s permission, what protection does any designer, illustrator or brand asset your business owns actually have, and what risk do you carry if your own marketing uses AI-generated images that lean too closely on someone else’s copyrighted work?

Nick Buckland, an intellectual property lawyer at Lewis Silkin, told the BBC that proving copyright infringement against an AI firm is not straightforward. “Generative AI doesn’t copy, it trains,” he said, explaining that this distinction is what AI companies rely on to argue they are not infringing. He added that two German cases had succeeded where music collecting societies showed AI companies had copied lyrics verbatim and presented them, the BBC reports, suggesting verbatim reproduction is the clearer legal test rather than general style similarity.

What’s actually happening right now

Scheffler’s case is not the only one in motion. OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT, is already being sued by German publishing group Penguin Random House, together with author and illustrator Ingo Siegner, over the Little Dragon Coconut character, according to the BBC. The Munich Regional Court is expected to decide that case in spring 2027. An OpenAI spokesperson told the BBC: “We’re having productive conversations with rightsholders around the world about supporting creativity, including fan art, while protecting intellectual property and taking appropriate action in response to copyright complaints,” adding that copyright holders can submit disputes directly with the company.

For context on scale, the Gruffalo books have sold more than 18 million copies worldwide, the BBC reports, and Scheffler has said any legal action would be about protecting creators generally rather than about compensation.

What to do now

This is a live legal question, not a settled one, so there is no instant fix. But three practical steps make sense for any owner using AI tools today:

  • Check the terms of service of whichever AI image or content tool your business uses, and look specifically for how the provider handles copyright disputes, since OpenAI’s own statement points owners toward submitting complaints directly.
  • Avoid prompting AI tools to recreate specific, recognisable characters, logos or illustration styles belonging to someone else, even for internal mock-ups, given that Buckland’s comments suggest distinctiveness strengthens a creator’s case.
  • If your business commissions or publishes AI-generated marketing content, build a quick human review step before anything goes live. Smart SME’s look at how 83% of marketers already edit AI content before posting shows this is becoming standard practice, not caution for its own sake.

Owners weighing up AI tools more broadly, including where firms are now restricting what AI can touch, may find it useful to read how banks have started blocking AI agents from customer accounts, and how younger staff are reacting to AI in the workplace, both signs that rules around AI use are tightening across sectors, not just publishing.

Is Axel Scheffler suing an AI company right now?

No. He told the BBC he is “seriously considering” legal action and has been in touch with a lawyer in Germany, but he has not named a company or confirmed a filing.

Has any AI company actually been sued over a children’s book character?

Yes. Penguin Random House and illustrator Ingo Siegner are suing OpenAI in Germany over the Little Dragon Coconut character, with a decision expected from the Munich Regional Court in spring 2027, the BBC reports.

Why is Germany the focus of these cases?

Scheffler told the BBC he believes the European Union offers a more creator-friendly legal route, and lawyer Nick Buckland pointed to two prior German cases where music collecting societies won against AI firms over verbatim copying.

Takeaway: the legal line between AI “training” and copyright “copying” is still being drawn in the courts, so until it is, keep a human checking anything AI-generated before it reaches your customers.