Card Surcharging Has Been Banned in the UK Since 2018: What SMEs Need to Know Instead

If your business quietly adds a fee when a customer pays by card, that practice has actually been against the rules since January 2018, and it is worth checking the habit has not crept back in. The card surcharging ban means the cost of accepting cards has to come out of your own margin rather than being passed to the customer at the till or on the invoice, a point Xero makes in its guidance for small businesses on the cost of taking card payments.

The short version: surcharging on everyday consumer debit and credit cards has been unlawful in the UK since January 2018, and the direction of travel is towards closing the remaining gaps. If you have been leaning on a card fee to cover your payment processing costs, now is the moment to work out what that habit is really worth and where else you can claw the money back.

What surcharging actually is, and what the rules say

Surcharging means charging a customer extra specifically because they chose to pay by card. A classic example is the takeaway or corner shop that adds 50p, or the tradesperson whose invoice reads “add 2.5% for card payments”.

Under the Payment Services Regulations 2017, which took effect on 13 January 2018, businesses in the UK cannot surcharge consumers for paying with Visa or Mastercard consumer debit and credit cards. The rules came out of European payments law but remain in force here. Enforcement sits with the authorities including Trading Standards and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), and a customer who spots an unlawful surcharge can complain and seek their money back.

For a while there were edges the rules did not fully cover, such as commercial and corporate cards and certain other payment methods. Xero, because that ability is being squeezed out. If you want the detail from the source, it is worth reading Xero’s guidance alongside the FCA’s material on card payments.

What it means for your bottom line

Card acceptance is not free. Every time a customer taps or inserts a card, your payment provider takes a cut. For a small business that fee is typically somewhere between roughly 1.4% and 1.9% per transaction on the simple flat-rate plans, plus any monthly hardware or software costs. Surcharging was a way of pushing that cost onto the customer. Take it away and the fee lands on you.

Work the numbers on your own trade. A cafe turning over £8,000 a month on cards at an effective 1.7% is paying around £136 a month, or roughly £1,600 a year, in processing fees. A trades business invoicing £40,000 a month, much of it on card, could be looking at several thousand pounds a year. If you were recovering even part of that through a surcharge, that is money you now absorb.

This is the same margin maths that makes the real cost of a failed card payment worth understanding: small percentages on high volumes add up fast, and the businesses that stay profitable are the ones that watch them.

Your options once surcharging is off the table

You cannot bill the customer for choosing a card. You can still do plenty about the underlying cost.

  • Renegotiate or switch provider. Card processing is competitive and rates are not fixed in stone. Moving from a legacy contract to a cheaper flat rate, or vice versa if you have grown, can cut your effective fee.
  • Build the cost into your prices. Instead of a visible surcharge, a modest, even uplift across your pricing spreads the cost without singling out card payers, which is exactly what the rules intend.
  • Steer larger payments to cheaper rails. For big invoices, bank transfer, Direct Debit or open banking payments carry far lower fees than cards. Providers such as GoCardless specialise in this.
  • Reduce failed and repeat transactions, which quietly cost you fees and time.

Card providers UK small businesses actually shortlist

If the fee is now yours to swallow, the provider you choose matters more than ever. The market is broader than the household names, so it pays to compare the specialists too. The table below sets out the sort of providers a UK small business would genuinely put on a shortlist. Treat the rates as published headline figures that change often, and always confirm current pricing before you sign.

Provider Best suited to Model Notes
SumUp Market traders, mobile sellers, low volume Flat per-transaction rate, no monthly tie-in on entry plans Cheap reader, pay as you go, simple to start
Zettle by PayPal Small shops and cafes wanting PayPal integration Flat per-transaction rate Ties into the wider PayPal ecosystem
Square Retail and hospitality wanting POS plus payments Flat rate plus optional software tiers Strong point-of-sale and online tools bundled in
Dojo Busy hospitality and higher-volume shops Custom, negotiated pricing Fast next-day settlement is a selling point
takepayments Established SMEs wanting a UK account manager Bespoke merchant service quotes Traditional merchant model, negotiable rates
Tyl by NatWest SMEs wanting a bank-backed provider Bespoke pricing Backed by NatWest, transparent pricing focus

The lesson is to look past the two or three names you already know. A challenger like Dojo or a bank-owned option like Tyl by NatWest may quote very differently from the pay-as-you-go readers, and the right fit depends on your volume, ticket size and whether you sell in person, online or both.

Where your software fits in

Once surcharging stops padding your takings, tight bookkeeping becomes the way you protect margin. Reconciling card settlements against your bank feed quickly tells you what fees are really costing, and features like Xero’s automated bank reconciliation reduce the admin of matching card payouts to invoices. That visibility is what lets you spot when a provider’s effective rate has crept up.

The same discipline helps on the invoicing side. If you can push customers to pay faster and by cheaper methods, you both cut fees and improve cash flow, which matters given how often small firms are left chasing money. Our guide to pushing back on late payment covers the mechanics.

Frequently asked questions

Can I still add a card fee to invoices?

No, not for consumers paying with standard Visa or Mastercard debit and credit cards. That has been banned since January 2018, and any remaining edges are narrowing. Do not build your pricing around a card surcharge.

What about a minimum spend for card payments?

Setting a minimum transaction value, such as “card payments over £5 only”, is a separate matter from surcharging and is generally at the merchant’s discretion, provided it is applied fairly and made clear to customers. It is not the same as charging a customer extra for using a card.

Can I still offer a discount for cash?

Offering an incentive to pay by one method, such as a cash discount, is treated differently from penalising card users with a surcharge. Any such discount must be genuine and clearly communicated. If in doubt, take advice, because presenting a card fee as a “cash discount” to dodge the rules will not wash.

How much do card fees actually cost a small business?

On simple flat-rate plans, expect roughly 1.4% to 1.9% per transaction, plus any monthly or hardware charges. Bespoke merchant contracts can be lower on high volumes but come with more moving parts. Your effective rate is what matters, so check total fees against total card takings.

Are bank transfers and open banking cheaper than cards?

Generally yes, especially for larger payments, because they avoid card scheme fees. Providers such as GoCardless for Direct Debit and various open banking tools can settle payments at a fraction of card costs, which is why steering big invoices away from cards is worth doing.

What to do next

  • Stop any surcharging now. Check your tills, card machines, websites and invoice templates for card fees and remove them to stay on the right side of the rules.
  • Work out your real card cost. Total your processing fees for the last quarter, divide by card takings, and you have your effective rate. That is the number to beat.
  • Get two or three fresh quotes. Compare a pay-as-you-go option like SumUp or Zettle against a negotiated provider such as Dojo, takepayments or Tyl by NatWest, and route large invoices to bank transfer or open banking where you can.
  • Adjust prices deliberately, not defensively. If you need to recover the cost, build a modest, even uplift into your prices rather than reaching for a surcharge, and keep your bookkeeping tight so you can see the effect.